Mutiny Pirate Bar and Island Grille

Reviews about Mutiny Pirate Bar and Island Grille

• 4 / 5

  By Josh Massey
  Great atmosphere. The rum selection was outstanding and the cocktails we had were superb. Food was solid, nothing outstanding...but completely good. The Calypso Fries were pretty terrific.
  Note that you are driving into a residential area, so it will seem odd as you're driving down the road.
  Our waitress was terrific and was considerate to our toddler...even brought her a toy to play with.
  Give it a shot.
  January 17, 2017
• 5 / 5

  By Dan Gravante
  I have been coming here regularly for a few months, maybe 2 months after they opened. I have had almost everything on the menu and not once have I been let down with the quality or the flavor of the food. They serve local craft brews from Clipper City as well as a few others, but they also have 120 some different bottles of rum. Do yourself a favor and get a passport and try every one of them. You will especially like Kilo Kai.
  
  Update: 4 years later and this is still my favorite place. I just came back from 1.5 years overseas and this is the only place i wanted to come back to for food and good atmosphere. I get my wish tonight. I even had restaurants overseas attempt to create the Shipwreck burger...its the best burger ever.
  November 17, 2016
• 5 / 5

  By Zack Bishop
  If you go, Ann is one of the best servers I've had!! The food is very good, the drinks are inventive (though I'm not the biggest rum fan). Their beer selection is, from what I can recall, most of your common stuff. I highly recommend the fried macaroni appetizer!
  September 01, 2016